|Year : 2016 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 29-36
Diagnostic methods for early detection of dental caries - A review
Madhumitha Mohanraj1, V Ratna Prabhu2, R Senthil3
1 Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, RVS Dental College, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India
2 Senior Consultant, KKCTH, Child Trust Hospital, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
3 Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, Meenakshi Ammal Dental College, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
|Date of Web Publication||7-Sep-2016|
D225, Manchester Grand Apartments, M. G. Road, Avarampalayam, Coimbatore - 641 006, Tamil Nadu
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Management of dental caries demands early detection of carious lesions. This article provides an overview of the state of the art methodologies for the detection and assessment of early carious lesions. This review is based on PubMed for available literature on caries detection methodology and tools, using terms such as "early detection of caries," "caries detection methods or tools," "transillumination," "fluorescence," and "newer caries detection method," Conventional or the traditional methods for the detection of caries have failed to detect early incipient caries effectively. The advanced methods provide promising results in detection both early caries and also caries occurring on all surfaces of the tooth, which paves the way for a more preventive approach to caries management. Each caries detection tool has advantages and disadvantages; some perform better on certain surfaces than others. Newer diagnostic methods which are still under research may prove to be very effective for early detection of caries in the near future. The change in the paradigm to minimally invasive dentistry has ascertained the field of dentistry to a more preventive approach to caries management, which demands a proper caries risk assessment and an early detection of caries. Not all the methods accurately detect early lesions. Hence, the clinician must ascertain as to which method and diagnostic tool should be used for clinical assessment of early detection of caries.
Keywords: Caries detection methods, early detection of caries, fluorescence, transillumination
|How to cite this article:|
Mohanraj M, Prabhu V R, Senthil R. Diagnostic methods for early detection of dental caries - A review. Int J Pedod Rehabil 2016;1:29-36
|How to cite this URL:|
Mohanraj M, Prabhu V R, Senthil R. Diagnostic methods for early detection of dental caries - A review. Int J Pedod Rehabil [serial online] 2016 [cited 2019 Aug 18];1:29-36. Available from: http://www.ijpedor.org/text.asp?2016/1/1/29/189973
| Introduction|| |
Diagnosis is an art and science, which results from the synthesis of scientific knowledge and clinical experiences in identifying the signs and symptoms of a disease process.
Dental caries is a complex disease, defined as the process of progressive demineralization of inorganic component of the tooth accompanied by disintegration of the organic portion.  It is a dynamic disease process, in which early lesions undergo many demineralization and remineralization cycles before being expressed clinically. Therefore, recognition of the initiation and early detection of caries should be the primary concern rather than the search for cavities.
Need for accurate diagnosis before cavitation would permit targeted preventive treatment such as fluorides and pit and fissure sealants, thereby significantly improving dental health and reducing the need for extensive drilling and filling.
Diagnostic methods become the science behind the creation of diagnosis. A clinician requires knowledge, ability, and skill to apply the right diagnostic method and to interpret them. Visual examination using mouth mirrors, probes, and conventional radiography were the diagnostic methods commonly used earlier. The results of several studies indicate that the use of probe has limited value in caries detection and is also known to disrupt remineralization. 
Modern dentistry emphasizes more on prevention, and hence the original maxim of "extension for prevention" has been eschewed for a minimal intervention approach.
| An Ideal Diagnostic Tool|| |
Tools to assess future caries risk and present caries activity are required, as diagnostic tasks are becoming more difficult and important from the standpoint of long-term oral health.
Ideally, a diagnostic tool should:
Requisites of an ideal diagnostic tool
- Detect dental caries at its earliest stage possible
- Provide valid prospective caries risk assessments for different age groups
- Determine present caries activity and monitor lesions behavior over time.
Qualitative versus quantitative methods
- Easy to apply
- Useful for all surfaces of teeth
- Identifying caries adjacent to restorations
- Quantitative analysis. 
- Conventional or traditional tools are qualitative in nature
- They show a poor validity with low sensitivity and moderate specificity
- This implies that caries diagnosis, as normally performed in daily clinical practice, is an inexact procedure that results in both over- and under-diagnosis. This has paved way to search for quantitative detection methods
- Advanced diagnostic methods are all quantitative in nature.  They detect lesions at an earlier stage and are more reliable than the conventional methods. 
| Advanced Methods of Caries Detection|| |
The following are methods of advanced caries detection [Table 1].
|Table 1: Advantages and disadvantages of advanced diagnostic methods for early detection of caries |
Click here to view
Digital radiographic methods
- Digital image enhancement
- Digital subtraction radiography
- Tuned-aperture computed tomography (TACT).
- Optical caries monitor
- Quantitative fiber-optic transillumination
- Digital Image fiber-optic transillumination
- Quantitative light/laser-induced fluorescence (QLF).
- DIAGNOdent - Laser autofluorescence.
- Electrical conductance measurement
- Electrical impedance measurement.
- Ultrasonic caries detector.
| Digital Radiographic Methods|| |
Digital imaging is an image formed and represented by a spatially distributed set of discrete sensors and pixels. There are two types:
- Direct - The direct image receptor that collects X-ray directly, for example, RVG [Figure 1] and [Figure 2]
- Indirect - For example, video camera is used for forming digital images of a radiograph.
Digital image enhancement
- Charged couple device (CCD)
- Complementary metal oxide semiconductor
- Photo Stimulable Phosphor plate (PSP).
Digital subtraction radiography
- Resolution of unenhanced digital image is lower than radiographs
- Range of gray shades is limited to 256, whereas in a radiographic film, over 1 million shades of gray appear
- Contrast can be digitally enhanced using a mathematical rule often decided by the algorithm/filter
- They are not practically used because they are very time-consuming.
- A digital bitewing radiograph is taken and later a second radiograph of exactly the same region is produced with identical exposure time, tube current, and voltage
- By subtracting gray values for each coordinate of the first radiograph from equivalent coordinate of second, a subtraction image is obtained [Figure 3]
- If no changes have occurred, the result of subtraction is zero
- Nonzero result will be obtained in case of onset or progression of demineralization
- It is not yet routinely applied in clinical caries detection due to difficulty of image registration.
Tuned-aperture computed tomography
This method constructs radiographic section through teeth. The slices can be viewed for the presence of radiolucency [Figure 4].
Mechanism of action
As exposure begins, the tube and film move in opposite directions simultaneously through a mechanical linkage. With this synchronous movement, images of objects in the focal plane remain in fixed positions on radiographic film and are clearly imaged.
On the other hand, images of objects located outside focal plane have continuously changing positions on the film. As a result, images of these objects are blurred beyond recognition by motion unsharpness. Slices can be brought together in a three-dimensional computer model called pseudo-hologram. TACT slices and pseudo-hologram can adequately detect small primary and secondary carious lesions. 
| Visible Light|| |
Optical caries monitor
- Principle used is that in white spot carious lesion, scattering is stronger than in sound enamel surface
- Light is transported through a fiber bundle to the tip of handpiece. Tip is placed against the tooth surface and reflected light is collected by different fibers of the same tip [Figure 5]. 
Digital imaging fiber-optic transillumination
Digital imaging fiber-optic transillumination (DIFOTI) was developed in an attempt to reduce the perceived shortcomings of FOTI, by combining FOTI with a digital CCD camera. DIFOTI has elevated traditional transillumination to more sophisticated diagnostic levels [Figure 6].
Mechanism of action
It uses a safe white light with which images taken from all the tooth surfaces can be digitally captured using a digital CCD and sent to a computer for analysis. Receptor with photocells converts photon energy to electrical energy - transmitted to a video processor and converted into color value and displayed on video monitor.
When the teeth are transilluminated, areas of demineralized enamel or dentin scatter light and incipient caries appear darker in the resultant image. Images taken during different examinations can be compared for clinical changes between several images of the same tooth over time. 
Quantitative light/laser-induced fluorescence
The use of fluorescence for the detection of caries dates back to 1929 first described by Benedict. Fluorescence results from change in the characteristics of light caused by a change in wavelength of incident light rays following reflection from the surface of material.
QLF is based on the principle of fluorescence. It enhances early detection of carious lesions, particularly progression or regression of white spots of smooth surface lesions. It provides a fluorescent image of a tooth surface within yellow-green spectrum of visible light that quantifies mineral loss and size of the lesion [Figure 7].
It is a suitable method for quantitative assessment of early enamel lesions in visually inaccessible areas. Most important parameters produced by QLF are lesion area, depth, and volume. 
Mechanism of action
System includes a measurement probe, control unit, and computer fitted with a frame grabber. The control unit consists of an illumination device and imaging electronics. Light source is a special arc lamp based on xenon technology. The light from this lamp is filtered by a blue-transmitting filter. A liquid light guide transports blue light to the teeth. Recording of florescent image is done with a yellow transmitting filter positioned in front of the color CCD sensor. Image is then digitized by the frame grabber and is available for quantitative analysis. Tooth is seen on a computer monitor as fluorescent green and dark areas indicate mineral loss or white spot lesions. Image can be saved and compared over time to track demineralization or remineralization [Figure 8].
|Figure 8: (a-c) Tooth is seen on the computer monitor as fluorescent green and dark areas indicate mineral loss|
Click here to view
At times, a red fluorescence appears that indicates leaking around restorations and sealants. It is emitted by porphyrins metabolized by bacteria in dental biofilm, calculus, or an infective carious lesion and usually indicates a high caries activity. Area of concern can be tracked over time to evaluate the success of remineralization. 
| Laser Light|| |
DIAGNOdent - laser autofluorescence
DIAGNOdent was first introduced in 1998 to aid the diagnosis of occlusal caries in adjunct to visual and radiographic examination. It is a variant of QLF system and was introduced based on research by Hibst and Gal.
DIAGNOdent system is a part of exciting new generation of dental equipment. It uses infrared laser fluorescence of 655 nm for the detection of occlusal and smooth surface caries [Figure 9]. 
Mechanism of action
DIAGNOdent technology uses a simple laser diode to compare the reflection wavelength against a well-known healthy baseline to uncover decay.
At specific wavelength that the device operates, healthy tooth structure exhibits little or no fluorescence, resulting in very low scale readings on the display. Carious tooth structure exhibits fluorescence proportionate to the degree of caries, resulting in elevated scale readings on the display. 
The unit has a fiber-optic cable that transmits light source to a handpiece that contains a fiber-optic eye in the tip. First, the laser diode is aimed at the healthy enamel tooth structure to obtain a benchmark reading. After calibration, it is moved to inspect all the surfaces of the teeth, shining the laser at 2.5 mm into all suspected areas.
As the laser pulses into grooves, fissures, and cracks, it reflects fluorescent light with particular wavelength. This is because light is absorbed by the organic and inorganic components of the tooth which induce infrared fluorescence.
This fluorescence is collected at the top of handpiece and transmitted back to the DIAGNOdent unit. Light is measured by receptors, converted into an acoustic signal, and evaluated electronically to reveal values between 0 and 99 [Figure 10]. 
DIAGNOdent pen is an advancement made in the DIAGNOdent technology. DIAGNOdent pen 2190 is the perfect tool to detect fissure and smooth surface caries accurately [Figure 11]. 
| Electric Current|| |
Electrical conductance measurement
Electrochemical machining (ECM) is based on the principle that a demineralized tooth has more pores filled with water or saliva, and this is more conductive than intact tooth surface.
It was first proposed by Magitot in 1878. Greater the amount of demineralization, higher is the electrical conductivity through enamel. Demineralized sites and sites with high pore volume and cavities can be detected by measuring the conductance. 
This technique has two methods of application.
Applies probe as electrode into fissures and the electrical conductance of that site is measured. To prevent current from leaking through superficial layer of moisture through the gingival, airflow is applied to dry the tooth surface around the probe. Disadvantage is that only small areas of occlusal surface can be measured at one time [Figure 12].
This technique measures the entire occlusal surface, which is covered with an electrolyte-containing medium where the electrode is placed. ECM uses a fixed frequency of 23 Hz alternate current [Figure 13]. 
Two instruments based on the difference in electrical conductance of carious and sound enamel were developed.
Vanguard electronic caries detector
It used a current of 25 Hz. Measured conductance was then converted to an ordinary scale of 0-9. Moisture and saliva were removed by a continuous stream of air to prevent surface conductance.
It used a current of 400 Hz. Measured conductance was then converted to four colored lights.
This method requires pits and fissures to be moistened with saline.
- Green: No caries
- Yellow: Enamel caries
- Orange: Dentin caries
- Red: Pulpal involvement.
Electrical impedance measurement
Electrical impedance measurement is a measure of degree at which an electric circuit resists electric current flow when a voltage is applied across two electrodes. Caries tissue has a lower impedance than sound tooth. It is also known as electronic caries monitor. 
| Ultrasound Caries Detector|| |
Use of ultrasound to detect dental caries has been proposed for the past 30 years, but the technique has received renewed interest particularly in the past 10 years. It was introduced for detecting early carious lesions on smooth surfaces.
Demineralization of natural enamel is assessed by ultrasound pulse-echo technique. It is observed that there is a definite correlation between the mineral content of the body of the lesion and the relative echo amplitude changes. 
Ultrasound makes the use of sound waves with frequency. They are longitudinal or pressure waves which travel through gasses, liquids, and solids. Ultrasound interacts differently with different tissues.
They have a frequency of >20,000 Hz and have all the properties of waves, in that they may be reflected, scattered, refracted, or absorbed. The relative ability of a medium to reflect sound depends on its mechanical properties such as elasticity, density, and wavelength of sound.
Amount of sound reflected provides information about the structure of reflecting interface, whereas the time taken for sound to be reflected provides information about the position of the reflecting interface. Sound waves produced as a result of minute changes in crystal dimension may be omitted continually, as burst of waves or as a single pulse.
Mechanism of action
For sound waves to reach the tooth, they have to travel through a coupling medium or an agent which has acoustic impedance. Various acoustic coupling agents have been used such as mercury, aluminum rods, water, and glycerin.
An ultrasonic probe is used which sends and receives longitudinal waves to and from the surface of the tooth. Initial white spot lesions produce no or weak surface echoes, whereas sites with visible cavitation produce echoes with substantially higher amplitude.
This method if improved can be a realistic alternative to radiographic diagnosis of caries on approximal surfaces. It is also more sensitive than visual-tactile method.
| Newer Technologies in Store for the Future|| |
Current and future technologies lay emphasis on the objective measurement of the properties of light waves, namely, scattering reflection, absorption, and fluorescence. 
Newer technologies include
Mechanism of light in detection of dental caries
- Multiphoton imaging ,
- Infrared fluorescence ,
- Infrared thermography ,
- Terahertz imaging 
- Optical coherence tomography 
- Polarized Raman spectroscopy ,
- Modulated (frequency-domain) infrared photothermal radiometry. ,
- The regular structure of teeth ensures good propagation of light through the crystalline enamel and tubules of dentin and disruption to structure of a tooth increases likelihood of scattering
- Uptake of fluid into pores created by demineralization in addition to the uptake of exogenous stain, bacterial breakdown products, and other contaminants present as a result of caries process will change the normal interaction of light with tooth structure
- In addition to scattering, these changes will include absorption and fluorescence
- Many of the newer techniques use one or more of these interactions. 
| Conclusion|| |
The shift in treatment philosophy from "extension for prevention" to "minimally invasive dentistry" has afforded the dentist the opportunity to diagnosis and manage caries at an early stage.
An ideal caries detection method should capture the whole continuum of caries process, from the earliest to the cavitation stage. It should be accurate, precise, easy to apply, and useful for all surfaces of teeth, as well as for caries adjacent to restorations.
More technologically, advanced measures based on optical properties (fluorescence and transillumination) are the most potent methods for the detection of incipient carious lesions.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Shafer WG. Textbook of Oral Pathology. 6 th
ed. Bangalore: Prism Book Pvt. Ltd.; 1997. p. 409-45.
Zandoná AF, Zero DT. Diagnostic tools for early caries detection. J Am Dent Assoc 2006;137:1675-84.
Tranaeus S, Shi XQ, Lindgren LE, Trollsås K, Angmar-Månsson B. In vivo
repeatability and reproducibility of the quantitative light-induced fluorescence method. Caries Res 2002;36:3-9.
Angmar-Månsson B, ten Bosch JJ. Advances in methods for diagnosing coronal caries - a review. Adv Dent Res 1993;7:70-9.
Ludlow JB, Mol A. Oral Radiology: Principles and Interpretation: Digital Imaging. 5 th
ed. Missouri: Mosby; 2004. p. 225-64.
Vaarkamp J, ten Bosch JJ, Verdonschot EH, Bronkhoorst EM. The real performance of bitewing radiography and fiber-optic transillumination in approximal caries diagnosis. J Dent Res 2000;79:1747-51.
Yang J, Dutra V. Utility of radiology, laser fluorescence, and transillumination. Dent Clin North Am 2005;49:739-52.
Stookey GK. Quantitative light fluorescence: A technology for early monitoring of the caries process. Dent Clin North Am 2005;49:753-70, vi.
Adeyemi AA, Jarad FD, Komarov GN, Pender N, Higham SM. Assessing caries removal by undergraduate dental students using quantitative light-induced fluorescence. J Dent Educ 2008;72:1318-23.
Shi XQ, Welander U, Angmar-Månsson B. Occlusal caries detection with KaVo DIAGNOdent and radiography: An in vitro
comparison. Caries Res 2000;34:151-8.
Aleksejuniene J, Tranaeus S, Skudutyte-Rysstad R. DIAGNOdent - an adjunctive diagnostic method for caries diagnosis in epidemiology. Community Dent Health 2006;23:217-21.
Pretty IA. Caries detection and diagnosis: Novel technologies. J Dent 2006;34:727-39.
Kühnisch J, Bücher K, Hickel R. The intra/inter-examiner reproducibility of the new DIAGNOdent Pen on occlusal sites. J Dent 2007;35:509-12.
Thylstrup A, Fejerskov O. Textbook of Cariology. 1 st
ed. Denmark: Munksgaard; 1985. p. 16-27.
Ashley PF, Blinkhorn AS, Davies RM. Occlusal caries diagnosis: An in vitro
histological validation of the Electronic Caries Monitor (ECM) and other methods. J Dent 1998;26:83-8.
Hall A, Girkin JM. A review of potential new diagnostic modalities for carious lesions. J Dent Res 2004;83:C89-94.
Olmez A, Tuna D, Oznurhan F. Clinical evaluation of diagnodent in detection of occlusal caries in children. J Clin Pediatr Dent 2006;30:287-91.
Goel A, Chawla HS, Gauba K, Goyal A. Comparison of validity of DIAGNOdent with conventional methods for detection of occlusal caries in primary molars using the histological gold standard: An in vivo
study. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent 2009;27:227-34.
Mendes FM, Siqueira WL, Mazzitelli JF, Pinheiro SL, Bengtson AL. Performance of DIAGNOdent for detection and quantification of smooth-surface caries in primary teeth. J Dent 2005;33:79-84.
Huysmans MC, Kühnisch J, ten Bosch JJ. Reproducibility of electrical caries measurements: A technical problem? Caries Res 2005;39:403-10.
Lin PY, Lyu HC, Hsu CY, Chang CS, Kao FJ. Imaging carious dental tissues with multiphoton fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy. Biomed Opt Express 2010;2:149-58.
Karlsson L. Caries detection methods based on changes in optical properties between healthy and carious tissue. Int J Dent 2010;2010:270729.
Kaneko K, Matsuyama K, Nakashima K. Quantification of early carious lesions by using an infrared camera in vitro
. In: Stookey GK, editor. Early Detection of Dental Caries II: Proceedings of the 4 th
Annual Indiana Conference. Indianapolis: Indiana University School of Dentistry; 1999. p. 83-100.
Matsuyama K, Nakashima S, Kaneko K. An in vitro
study on the detection of early enamel carious lesions by use of an infrared camera. Caries Res 1998;32:294.
Berry E, Fitzgerald AJ, Zinov'ev NN, Walker GC, Homer-Vanniasinkam S, Sudworth CD. Optical Properties of Tissue Measured Using Terahertz Pulsed Imaging. Proceedings of SPIE: Medical Imaging 2003: Physics of Medical Imaging; 2003. p. 459-70.
Choo-Smith LP, Dong CC, Cleghorn B, Hewko M. Shedding new light on early caries detection. J Can Dent Assoc 2008;74:913-8.
Ionita I. Diagnosis of tooth decay using polarized Micro-Raman confocal spectroscopy. Rom Rep Phys 2009;61:567-74.
Jeon RJ, Han C, Mandelis A, Sanchez V, Abrams SH. Diagnosis of pit and fissure caries using frequency-domain infrared photothermal radiometry and modulated laser luminescence. Caries Res 2004;38:497-513.
Jeon RJ, Matvienko A, Mandelis A, Abrams SH. Interproximal dental caries detection using Photo Thermal Radiometry (PTR) and Modulated Luminescence (LUM). Eur Phys J Spec Top 2008;153:467-9.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4], [Figure 5], [Figure 6], [Figure 7], [Figure 8], [Figure 9], [Figure 10], [Figure 11], [Figure 12], [Figure 13]